top of page
ChatGPT Image Oct 4, 2026, 03_26_23 PM.png
Screenshot 2026-10-03 at 10.24.58 am.png

An unexpected connection between Queen Victoria Hospital and a city that would become part of our own story.

We started this story in East Grinstead.

Queen Victoria Hospital.
Archibald McIndoe.
The Guinea Pig Club.

The men who came to Sussex badly burned and badly injured — and the remarkable way in which they were treated.

But when we started digging a little deeper, we found that the story didn't stop at East Grinstead.

It crossed the sea.

and it led us back to South Africa

The South African Connection - Jack Penn

Screenshot 2026-10-03 at 4.08.04 pm.png

Jack Penn was born in Cape Town in 1909 and grew up in Johannesburg.

During the Second World War he came to Britain, where he became involved in the rapidly developing field of plastic and reconstructive surgery.

And this brought him into the world of Archibald McIndoe.

McIndoe was dealing with some of the most devastating injuries of the war: burns, facial injuries and severe damage to hands and limbs.

Penn saw this new approach to reconstruction at close quarters.

Then he took that experience home.

Back in South Africa, he set about developing something of his own.

And that is where the story takes us to Johannesburg.

Brenthurst

Screenshot 2026-10-04 at 3.47.06 pm.png

When a family home became a wartime hospital

When a family home became a wartime hospital

In Johannesburg stood Brenthurst, the beautiful home of the Oppenheimer family.

During the war, with the assistance of the Oppenheimer family, Penn established the Brenthurst Military Hospital for Plastic Surgery there.

A private family home had become a hospital.

Men returning from war with terrible burns and injuries were brought there for treatment.

It was an extraordinary transformation.

But Penn wasn't simply treating patients.

He was helping to develop the speciality itself.

The Brenthurst Papers

More than just a medical record

While the Brenthurst Military Hospital was treating wounded servicemen, Jack Penn was also recording and sharing the work being done there.

The Brenthurst Papers was a medical journal edited by Penn and published by the hospital during the war. Six issues appeared between 1943 and 1944, documenting the developing techniques and ideas in plastic and reconstructive surgery.

It was an extraordinary undertaking for a wartime hospital — and became an important early record of the speciality as it was developing in South Africa.

Among the work associated with Brenthurst was the Brenthurst splint, developed for the treatment of severe facial and jaw injuries.

So Brenthurst wasn't simply a place where injured men were treated. It was also a place where new ideas were being developed, tested and shared.

A wartime hospital — and a new chapter in plastic surgery.

1944

By 1944, Brenthurst had become much more than just a beautiful Johannesburg home.

It was a hospital.

And inside it, Jack Penn and his team were doing pioneering work with men who had been badly burned and injured during the war.

Then, in 1944, fire tore through part of the estate.

It caused considerable damage and changed the course of the story.

The military authorities decided that the plastic-surgery patients should be brought together under one roof, and the unit was moved to a new location on the Tara estate at Hurlingham, in Johannesburg.

So the patients moved.

The work continued.

And Brenthurst itself was restored and eventually returned to Sir Ernest Oppenheimer.

But, rather surprisingly, the fire was not quite the end of the Brenthurst story.

In some ways, it helped set the stage for what came next.

Then came the fire

The Phoenix

Screenshot 2026-10-04 at 5.07.07 pm.png

And we came across something else.

The symbol associated with the Brenthurst Clinic was a phoenix rising from the flames.

Penn explained that it represented the pilots who had been brought down in flames — and who later flew again.

It seems almost perfectly chosen.

These were men who had come through fire.

Penn's work was about giving them the chance to move forward.

Not simply surviving their injuries.

But rebuilding their lives.

And suddenly, the connection with McIndoe and East Grinstead seemed even stronger.

Different country.

Different hospital.

But the same remarkable idea:

reconstruction was about much more than repairing a body.

ChatGPT Image Oct 6, 2026, 08_59_14 AM.png

from war to peace

When the war ended, Penn's work didn't end with it.

He moved increasingly into civilian practice and into teaching, helping to establish plastic and reconstructive surgery as an important academic discipline in South Africa.

Sir Ernest Oppenheimer subsequently funded the first Chair of Plastic, Maxillo-Facial and Oral Surgery at the University of the Witwatersrand.

And the man chosen to become its first professor was Jack Penn.

So the surgeon who had learned from the wartime experience in Britain, who had established Brenthurst and then moved to Tara, was now helping to shape the future of plastic surgery in South Africa.

But there was still one thing he wasn't prepared to leave behind.
 

The name Brenthurst.

At Tara, Penn continued his work with wounded servicemen.

And something rather interesting was happening alongside the surgery.

Plastic surgery in South Africa was beginning to develop into a speciality in its own right.

The experience gained during the war was helping to shape what came next.

And Jack Penn was right in the middle of it.

The fire had changed the location.

It hadn't stopped the work.

In fact, the story was about to move into a new chapter.

The work continued

The Brenthurst Clinic

Screenshot 2026-10-06 at 12.09.53 pm.png

The name lived on.

After the war, Penn established his own private practice in Johannesburg.

And when he did, he chose a name that took him straight back to where the story had begun.

THE BRENTHURST CLINIC

The original Brenthurst hospital had gone.

The house had been restored and returned to the Oppenheimer family.

But the name survived.

What had begun as a family home turned wartime hospital had become part of the name of Penn's own post-war surgical work.

And somehow, that seemed fitting.

Because Brenthurst had never really been just a building.

It had become part of the story of what Penn was trying to achieve.

ChatGPT Image Oct 7, 2026, 02_08_51 PM.png
And then something rather unexpected happened…
THE STORY BECAME PERSONAL
Until now, we'd been following somebody else's story.

McIndoe.
Jack Penn.
Brenthurst.
Tara.

 

Fascinating stuff, certainly.

But then, somewhere along the way, we discovered something rather extraordinary.

We had actually met Jack Penn.

Not in an archive.
Not in an old photograph.
Not in some long-forgotten piece of history.

We had sat with him.
In his home in Cape Town.

At the time, of course, we had no idea how significant that meeting would eventually become.

We simply knew him as a remarkable man with a lifetime of stories.

Years later, sitting in East Grinstead and following the trail from McIndoe to South Africa, we suddenly realised that the man we'd been reading about was the very same man whose study we'd once sat in.

And that changed everything.

We had sat with him.In his home in Cape Town.

The people on the shelves
Henrietta Stockdale
Albert Schweitzer

Statue of the pioneering nurse, at St Cyprian's Cathedral, Kimberley

bust, presented to Strasbourg.

Jan Christiaan Smuts

bust commissioned for Jan Smuts Airport

Cecilia Makiwane
Joseph Lister

sculpture of the pioneering nurse, unveiled at Victoria Hospital, Lovedale

bronze bust in England, at the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh

There was another rather extraordinary connection.

We hadn't simply discovered Jack Penn through our research.

We had actually met him.

Many years ago, Fran and I visited Penn at his beautiful home in Cape Town.

And he invited us into his study.

In Jack Penn's study

I remember the room being full of things that seemed to tell a story before he had even said a word.
 

Photographs.

Sculptures.

Objects.

Memories.
 

Penn began telling us about some of the remarkable people he had known during his long and extraordinary life.


Among the photographs and sculptures was Albert Schweitzer.


And rather than giving us some formal history lesson, Penn simply regaled us with stories.

Albert Schweitzer Study Still Life.png
One story led to another.
A study filled with photographs, sculptures and memories — much as we remember Jack Penn’s own study in Cape Town.
and then he showed us the rock

There was also one of those wonderfully strange little stories that you couldn't possibly have planned.

Penn told us about the building of his swimming pool.

Workers were blasting out rock when one piece was sent flying into the air.

It landed not far from him.

When he picked it up, he noticed something rather remarkable.

The shape of the rock appeared to show the Virgin Mary holding a child.

And it was surprisingly obvious.

Penn had kept it.

So there we were, standing in his study, looking at a piece of rock that had arrived rather dramatically from somewhere beneath his garden.

Whether you see a religious image in it or simply an extraordinary coincidence, Penn clearly thought it worth keeping.

And I rather like the fact that, amongst all the important photographs, sculptures and stories in that study, this strange little piece of rock had found its place too.

bottom of page