top of page

East Grinstead Martyrs
Three names. One terrible day. And a story hidden in the High Street.
You could walk along East Grinstead High Street today and never know.
There are shops. Cafés. People carrying shopping bags. Cars coming and going.
The usual business of an ordinary English town.
But nearly five hundred years ago, this same High Street witnessed something very different. On 18 July 1556, three people were burned at the stake in East Grinstead for refusing to renounce their Protestant faith. Their names were:
Thomas Dungate
John Forman
Ann Tree
Today, they are remembered by three memorial stones in the churchyard of St Swithun's.

And once you know the story, the High Street doesn't look quite so ordinary.

Three People
What strikes me most about their story is how little we actually know about them.
They weren't famous people.
They didn't leave behind grand houses or diaries or portraits.
They were simply three people who found themselves caught up in one of the most turbulent periods of religious change in English history.
Thomas Dungate is known to have lived in East Grinstead. He is believed to have been arrested at a farm near Crawley which became known as Martyrs Farm from 1556.
Ann Tree, sometimes called Mother Tree, is believed to have lived in the parish of West Hoathly.
And of John Forman, remarkably little is known.
In fact, local historical research suggests that the three may not all have been residents of East Grinstead at all.
The town may simply have been the place where they were brought to be executed.
Which somehow makes the story more haunting.
We know their names.
We know the date.
We know what happened.
But the people themselves have almost disappeared.
Why were they killed
To understand what happened, we have to go back to the reign of Mary I.
England was going through one of those periods when religion wasn't simply a matter of what you believed privately.
It could determine which church you attended, how you worshipped and whether the authorities considered your beliefs acceptable.
Following the religious changes of Henry VIII and Edward VI, Mary I came to the throne in 1553 and sought to restore Roman Catholic worship.
Those who refused to conform could be prosecuted for heresy.
And so, in the summer of 1556, the story arrived in East Grinstead.
Their last night
There is another intriguing part of the story.
Local tradition places the three in the cellars of the building now associated with Broadleys on the High Street on the night before their execution.
The Town Council recorded the tradition in 2015 when plans were being discussed to commemorate the martyrs in the High Street.
Whether every detail of that story can now be proved is difficult to establish, so I'd rather leave it as local tradition.
But just imagine it.
A building that is part of the ordinary High Street today.
People walking past.
Shops opening.
Cars going by.
And underneath it, according to the tradition, three people spending their final night in captivity.
The day
On 18 July 1556, Thomas Dungate, John Forman and Ann Tree were taken to the place of execution.
They were burned at the stake.
The exact position of the stake is no longer known.
Local historical research places it somewhere in the High Street, probably around the area of what is now Broadleys / the Old Bank Café.
And this is where I think the story becomes particularly powerful.
Because you can stand there today.
People are drinking coffee.
Someone is looking for somewhere to park.
A bus goes past.
And beneath all that ordinary modern life is the memory of three people who died there nearly five centuries ago.

From the High Street, the story takes you up towards St Swithun's Church.
There has been a church on this hilltop site since the medieval period, and the church remains one of the town's most visible landmarks.
And just outside the church, near the entrance, are the three memorial stones.

The three stones
There is something rather unusual about the memorial.
They aren't three ordinary gravestones.
They are memorial slabs, placed there centuries after the executions.
Local historical research records that in the late 19th or early 20th century,
Lady Musgrave had the stones inscribed and laid over ashes that
were then believed to be those of the martyrs.
And that qualification matters.
Their remains were never positively identified.
The Town Council describes the stones as memorial stones rather than graves.
The inscription bears the Latin:
FIDELES USQUE AD MORTEM
Faithful unto death.
And somehow that makes the stones more interesting.
We know the names.
We know the date.
But even now, there is uncertainty about what lies beneath them.
and then there's Ann Tree
Ann Tree's story takes us a little further into the Sussex countryside.
She is believed to have lived in the parish of West Hoathly, south-west of East Grinstead.
She became known as Mother Tree in John Foxe's account, which may suggest that she was an older woman.
There is also a memorial to her at St Margaret's Church in West Hoathly.
So her story doesn't really end in East Grinstead.
It reaches out into the villages and countryside around us.
And that is something we've discovered again and again since we started looking more closely at this part of Sussex.
The stories don't always stay where you expect them to.
and then the railings dissapeared
There is another little piece of history here that I rather like.
If you look around the churchyard today, you might notice that it doesn't quite have the ironwork you might expect from an old English churchyard.
During the Second World War, the internal railings in the churchyard were removed.
They became part of the wider wartime effort to collect scrap metal.
It seems a small thing now.
But think about the contrast.
These stones were put here to remember people who had died almost four hundred years earlier.
Then another generation came along and removed the iron railings because the country was fighting another war.
The iron went.
The stones remained.
nearly 500 years later
In June 2015, something rather unexpected happened in the High Street.
Workmen digging outside Broadleys for a water meter uncovered a bone.
Almost immediately, speculation began.
Could this possibly be connected with the three martyrs?
The police had the bone examined.
It wasn't human.
It was an animal bone.
And just like that, the mystery disappeared.
Or perhaps not.
Because the exact place where the three were executed is still uncertain.
The bone wasn't theirs.
Their remains haven't been identified.
And yet, for one brief moment, the past had literally appeared beneath the High Street.
I rather like that.
the High Street has a long memory
And perhaps that's what I like most about this story.
You don't need to go looking for a ruined castle.
You don't need to find an ancient battlefield.
You don't even need to leave the town centre.
You can stand in the High Street today and look around at an ordinary Saturday afternoon.
And underneath it all is another East Grinstead.
An East Grinstead of religious conflict, fear and uncertainty.
An East Grinstead where three ordinary people were led to their deaths because they refused to abandon what they believed.
Nearly five hundred years later, their names are still here.
Thomas Dungate.
John Forman.
Ann Tree.
And suddenly...
the High Street doesn't look quite so ordinary.
read more
bottom of page